Marco Carnelos – Middle East Eye Sept 12, 2026
Twenty-five years ago, I stood in my office on the 24th floor of the Italian mission to the UN in New York, watching smoke pour from the twin towers of the World Trade Center in southern Manhattan.
A quarter of a century later, the first question I ask myself is whether the country that suffered that heinous crime has changed – and the answer, unfortunately, is that it has: for the worse.
In the aftermath of 9/11, the United States stood at a crossroads. It could have chosen sober reflection, targeted justice and a long-overdue reckoning with the grievances that al-Qaeda’s extremists exploited. It chose instead the path of empire, invasion and endless war – a choice that has haunted the Middle East, and America itself, ever since.
The evidence of Washington’s failure to learn is now overwhelming. The US is once again mired in a war of choice in the Middle East – this time against Iran – while the Palestinian question, the central unresolved wound of the region, continues to fester untreated, fuelling the very anger and resentment that it claims to fight.
The “global war on terror” that George W Bush launched in 2001 was supposed to be a decisive campaign against al-Qaeda and its Taliban hosts, but it metastasised into a generational project of regime change and nation-building that left Afghanistan and Iraq in ruins, destabilised the broader region and birthed new enemies.
The invasion of Iraq in 2003, based on fabricated intelligence about weapons of mass destruction, unleashed years of violence that created the conditions for the rise of the Islamic State (IS) group. At least 200,000 Iraqi civilian deaths have been documented, and peer-reviewed studies put the true toll at half a million or more.
Forever wars
Afghanistan, after two decades of blood and treasure, was handed back to the same Taliban in 2021. The lesson seemed obvious: the United States could not bomb, invade or occupy its way to security in the Middle East.
Twenty-five years later, however, US President Donald Trump – who cast himself as a peacemaker and promised to end foreign wars – has launched what analysts are already calling his own forever war in Iran.
In February 2026, Trump announced “major combat operations” against Iran, launching massive joint US-Israeli strikes targeting military, government and infrastructure sites. More than six months later, the war grinds on with no clear exit strategy, no congressional authorisation, no UN resolution and scant support from Nato allies or the American public.
Sina Toossi, an analyst at the Center for International Policy, put it bluntly: “Trump has broken an important post-Iraq and Afghanistan constraint in Washington against launching another major, open-ended war in the Middle East. That could leave his successor inheriting … an entrenched US-Iran confrontation.”
The Strait of Hormuz – and increasingly also the Bab al-Mandeb – has become a flashpoint, pushing US petrol prices higher, weakening Trump’s approval ratings and undermining Washington’s international standing.
As with Iraq, the regional spillover has caught Washington off guard, leaving Gulf allies feeling helpless in the face of a war launched on a whim. Some of them are now considering other options for their security.
The failure to plan for the “day after” – a mistake former US President Barack Obama later called the worst of his presidency, over Libya – has been repeated yet again.
An untreated wound
For decades, the United States has claimed to be an “honest broker” between Israelis and Palestinians. In reality, as veteran US peace negotiator Aaron David Miller admitted, Washington has acted as “Israel’s lawyer” – a verdict the historian Rashid Khalidi has documented at length – guaranteeing that the so-called peace process would end in failure.
The Oslo Accords, the Camp David summit, the endless rounds of negotiations produced nothing but more settlements, more occupation and more Palestinian dispossession. The settler population of the occupied West Bank, excluding East Jerusalem, has more than quadrupled since the accords were signed in 1993, with scant protest from Washington.
Today, the two-state solution – the supposed cornerstone of US and international policy for decades – seems a mirage. The United States has claimed success even as its efforts have done more to destabilise and inflame the region than to contribute to lasting peace.
Trump’s Gaza plan has been condemned by critics as a blueprint for entrenching colonial power, in which Palestinians are spoken about – not spoken with – their political representatives excluded and their rights deferred indefinitely.
Meanwhile, the Iran war has diverted diplomatic attention away from Israel-Palestine, allowing Israeli settlement expansion and settler violence to continue in the West Bank while the Israeli military continues to kill civilians in Gaza.
The 9/11 attacks were carried out by men who fed on the very grievances – US military presence in Muslim lands, support for repressive regimes and indifference to Palestinian suffering – that Washington has spent 25 years deepening rather than addressing.
Lessons unlearned
The results of Washington’s twin failures – the perpetual war and the perpetual neglect of Palestine – are measurable in the collapse of American standing across the Arab world. Arab Barometer surveys conducted across eight Arab countries between August and November 2025, before Trump launched his war on Iran, found overwhelming majorities – 86 percent in Egypt and Jordan – saying Washington had sided with Israel over the Palestinians.
Nothing new here. As far back as 2002, polling found that Arabs actually liked American people, products, education and values but strongly disliked US policies towards the Arab world, especially regarding the Palestinians.
Bush’s famous claim that the attackers “hate our freedoms” was always a lie. They hated what the US did, the policies it pursued: the unconditional support for Israeli occupation, the invasions, the drone strikes, the double standards.
Those attitudes plummeted further with Trump’s first-term pro-Israel, anti-Muslim policies, and then with the Democrats’ support, under former US President Joe Biden, for Israel’s genocide in Gaza.
As polling analyst James Zogby has warned, Washington’s “lack of attentiveness to Arab sensitivities and needs contributes to making a bad situation even worse – further embittering Arabs toward the USA, deepening fissures within the Arab World”. Trump’s attacks on Iran, he has also written, are likely to make it “increasingly difficult for Arabs to like American values”.
The war on terror was supposed to make America safer; instead, it has made the world more dangerous, more polarised and more resentful. A quarter of a century later, the US is less trusted, less influential and less secure than it was on 10 September 2001.
What would it mean to learn the lessons of 9/11? It would mean recognising that military force cannot solve political problems; that occupations breed resistance, not stability; and that Palestinians are human beings with legitimate national aspirations, not a demographic problem or a piece of real estate to be managed.
It would also mean pursuing diplomacy with adversaries rather than regime change, and putting Washington’s weight behind international law and human rights rather than behind the whims of whichever Israeli government happens to be in power.
None of this has happened. The “lessons learned” industry that sprang up after 9/11 – the commissions, the reports, the think-tank panels – produced volumes of analysis but no fundamental change, and the United States remains trapped in a cycle of violence it helped create and refuses to break.
Twenty-five years after the towers fell, the fires still burn – in Gaza, in the West Bank, in Lebanon and in Iran, and in the hearts of millions who watched America’s promise of justice turn into a licence for endless war and indiscriminate killing.
The tragedy of 11 September 2001 was not only the loss of nearly 3,000 lives but also what America chose to become in response. Until Washington learns to see the Middle East through the eyes of those it has bombed, occupied and ignored, the cycle of anger and resentment will continue, generation after generation, with no end in sight.
—
Marco Carnelos is a former Italian diplomat. He has been assigned to Somalia, Australia and the United Nations. He served in the foreign policy staff of three Italian prime ministers between 1995 and 2011. More recently he has been Middle East peace process coordinator special envoy for Syria for the Italian government and, until November 2017, Italy’s ambassador to Iraq.

The Trump admin hasn’t really overlooked the consequences of oil flow restrictions.
They “wisely” prepared themselves before attacking Iran by invading Venezuela and seizing their oil.
Now, some uninformed people tell us: Oh, but Venezuelan oil is the crappiest oil in the world!
What they don’t take into account is that before nationalization most of the companies exploiting Venezuelan oil fields were american, and that much of it all went to the USA.
So, it is a rather cheap “analysis” when they say that Trump shot himself in the foot with the Venezuelan oil.
Do you think Americans are that dumb, especially in things having to do with oil?
Oil is a prime american industry, and much if not almost all oil technology is of american origin.
And don’t forget the Jews who control the Americans.
Do you think Jews are incompetent planners and plotters?
Marco Carnelos would have known of Giulietto Chiesa and Ferdinando Imposimato. Two Italian politicians who have researched 9/11 and didn’t accept the official narrative.
Middle East Eye, and this fella called Marco should know by now 9/11 wasn’t an Arab, Muslim terrorist attack. The USG claimed it was attacked by al-Qaeda and then used 9/11 to make war against countries it wanted to destroy. There was a time when the US even tried to implicate Iran. The 9/11 lie must be getting a little hollow these days because I don’t hear Trump and Co saying this is one of the reasons why we have to seek justice from Iran by bombing Iran…
I’ve watched only a few minutes of this week’s FFWN. I was pleased to hear Kevin Barrett and Wyatt Peterson say, people these days, especially the young believe Israel did it.
https://www.bitchute.com/video/uukQy699MDhi
> I watched the twin towers burn.
I watched a barbeque burn last night. The towers vaporised, or something. They didn’t burn. That’s like saying you went to bonfire and watched a whole town burn.
They spontaneously vaporised their DEWs with mini-nukes as a side dish.
It was just a coincidence that they “looked like” they were controlled demolishioned. Honest. Kiss kiss.
lieslieslies they will repeat still in 50 years .
Looking at his background and what he says, there is only one conclusion any sane and honest person can come to regarding the author of this article, which is that he is one more goddamn professional liar. Of course, he is being very “diplomatic” in going along with all of the Judeo-Americano lies about 9/11 and how in alleged self-defense the Americans from then launched their forever wars against the alleged terrors of al-Qaeda.
For those looking for leverage to convince a deluded US and Western public that the US-Israel forever wars were a mistake, one can understand the good intentions of Carnelos. Certainly there are still millions and millions of people in the US who faithfully believe all of the 9/11 official narratives, and many more who do not but will never admit it was a joint Judaeo-American job out of their fear of a complete loss of face on the world stage – musing over such questions in the privacy of their minds as, “How could our nation be so evil? How could we be so stupid?”. Still many others more aligned with an agenda of full-spectrum dominance, regardless of world opinion and internal opposition want to continue to rely on all of the fake official narratives.
So, to make milage Carnelos goes along with likely one of the biggest fake official narratives of all time, which is the 9/11 one, and to influence the Yanks to back off, he is virtually saying, “It is this madman Trump who has started his own forever war against Iran despite his promises, and we must use more peaceful methods to stop the terrorism in the Middle East.”. Sure, this may be a good diplomatic trick for candidates against the war to use in the upcoming American midterms, or in any effort during the elections to try to make the war against Iran an election issue. How else can a dissembling diplomat, even one with good intentions, get his crooked Italian boot in the door to offer the American people an honorable and respectable off-ramp to withdraw from their forever wars?
That would all be dandy, if the American people actually had any real influence to cancel the war against Iran and restore Palestine to the Palestinians. However, must they not first wake up and realize how they have been duped from the beginning regarding all of those wars in and around the Levant, and the fact that the US is essentially a military goon bashing around weaker nations on the world stage, while doing the wet work essentially for foreign interests? No that would not be very “diplomatic” would it? However, if such accusations likely would only give them more resolve to avoid the truth, does that not also mean that in reality most Americans really do not care about the truth, or the veracity of reasons for their wars, and all that they really care about is whatever serves their own interests and using their powers to serve their ends even if it means walking over the faces of any people or nation standing in the way of their designs, and that they, in fact, really know they are no different than the Israelis. Is that not the reasons why Israel and the US are really one nation being run by a totally Zio establishment which has absolutely NO moral limits?
However, just like during Covid, in the criminal minds of our rulers they only regard the lies which serve their interests, and they very much want to keep the official narrative of 9/11 alive. They are still using it as a pretext to call any aggression against USrale genocidal Lebensraum goals in the Middle East as “terrorism”. The Rothschild-US-Israeli establishment plans since the 1940’s have always been for a “Greater Israel”, and since the 1980’s and their march through the Middle East, they have always intended to take the vast resources of Iran and thereby to control West Asia. Hence, are not any of our efforts to appease any of them with tokens of fake diplomacy caving to any of their fake narratives only more fuel for their warfare fires?
Ceding to Judeo-US narratives, such as with the 9/11 one, are the very pretexts they are able to dupe the public that the wars are just and honorable. They are wars of aggression using the worst kind of butchers and mercenaries to rule as their puppets in all of the nations they conquer. They are not wars to liberate the people. They are wars for land and plunder. Until the Americans are fixed with that truth and see that they are being fed a constant diet of lies, while in the process looting their own nation, they will never rise up and end any of their wars.
Carnelos is offering what he believes to be a “diplomatic” off ramp. I do not what to get into Wop bashing, but being of a more-Northern mentality, I regard his efforts as scurrilous and as asymmetrical as much of modern Italian architecture, and very much echoed by the modernist Vatican curia dialoging with the devil while blessing his works under the new-normal of Holy Ambiguity.
You lost me at the fact you worked for the comlicit UN….And then went om a rant abpout the UN invented Al Qaeda!! YOU were part of the genocide and should HANG for your crimes you spineless coward shallow Italian circumcised JEW!!