Prof Robert Pape – Escalation Trap March 17, 2026
In my interview on Piers Morgan Uncensored, I made a simple point that cuts against much of the current commentary.
The biggest mistake right now is thinking Iran is losing.
By disrupting the Strait of Hormuz, Iran has already demonstrated an ability to impose costs on the global economy. That changes the strategic equation. The question is no longer simply what the United States can destroy, but whether it can reverse that disruption without triggering wider escalation.
This is the escalation trap.
What I did not have time to explain is that the conflict may now be approaching a more dangerous transition.
The escalation trap unfolds in stages. The first phase centers on strikes and counterstrikes. The second expands the conflict horizontally—across shipping, infrastructure, and regional targets. The next phase is more consequential.
Stage 3 is the turn toward ground forces.
If efforts to reopen the Strait intensify, pressure will grow for operations to physically secure key terrain—offshore islands, coastal launch sites, and staging areas along Iran’s periphery. These are not symbolic targets. They are locations that require sustained control.
That shift matters because ground operations change the structure of the conflict.
They create fixed positions to defend. They increase exposure of forces. They open new avenues for retaliation. And they make disengagement far more difficult once commitments are made.
This is where escalation pathways multiply.
Operations in the Gulf could expand into direct clashes on islands and coastal zones. Retaliation could extend beyond the immediate battlespace to regional bases, infrastructure, and partners. What begins as an effort to stabilize a chokepoint risks becoming a broader and more entrenched conflict.
The purpose of analysis is not to predict a single outcome. It is to identify the pathways that make certain outcomes more likely.
Right now, one of those pathways is becoming clearer.
This Sunday, I will hold a live Strategic Escalation Briefing focused on the coming battle for the Strait of Hormuz and the transition to this next phase.
We will examine how Stage 3 could unfold, what would trigger it, and the warning indicators to watch in the coming weeks.
Understanding these dynamics early is the difference between reacting to events and anticipating them.
Sunday, March 22 — 4:00pm CT / 5:00pm ET
Access to the live briefing is included with a paid subscription. Paid subscribers will receive the Zoom link by email prior to the event, along with a recording and written memo afterward.
If you want to be ahead of the risks now emerging in this conflict, this session is designed for you.
—
Robert Pape
—
Escalation Trap is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
“Prof”? Really? You’re kidding me.
LOFFFFL.
American forces are going to have to invade Iran, if they want to stop Iranian missiles and drones, keeping the Gulf closed.
Apparently it’s open, closed only to Iran’s enemies.
America is going to lose a lot of soldiers invading and occupying Western Iran. I wonder if America will abandon its bases in the Gulf instead?
As if the US couldn’t easily commandeer & take control of the Strait of Hormuz if it wanted to–thus revealing this is all a staged choreographed war to artificially increase the price of oil to dialectically progress the anti-oil program of the WEF-UN Agenda 2030.
Here’s the deal. The U.S. can go first in running the Hormuz gauntlet and then get back to us and let us know that how worked out for them. Then we’ll decide if we want to sign on.
Signed,
Everyone Else
At times of the Gulf War the USA had 800.000 troops and they shipped 300.000 over to Irak. Today they only have 470.000 plus 110.000 from the Marine Corps. Iran is 4 times the size of Irak with twice the amount of people and opposite to Irak the Iran is mainly mountains.
All odds are stacked against an invasion on the ground.
There will be no invasion of Iran Period!
@Mega Therion:
Simulations have been done and the US got its ass kicked.
“The best guess can be taken from the largest war game to be produced in Pentagon history, the Millennium Challenge 2002, which cost $250m. This war game pitted a red team, lead by retired Marine. Lt. Gen. Paul Van Riper, against a blue team, that represented the US army. . . . While simulated, had this been a real life, 20,000 US sailors and marines could have died. This was not the desired result, especially after the Pentagon had poured a quarter of a million dollars, two years and 13,500 participants into its development. In response, the game was reset and rigged to achieve the desired outcome.”
Strait of Hormuz: Millennium Challenge 2002 – the simulation that predicts how conflict between Iran and the US could go
https://www.nationalworld.com/your-world/millennium-challenge-2002-simulation-predicts-conflict-strait-of-hormuz-5189131