HenryMakow.com – March 16, 2026
“Many Palestinians (Muslim and Christian) are, according to Sand, the genetic and cultural descendants of the Jews who stayed in the land after the Roman period and later adopted new religions. This undermines claims that modern Jews have a unique ethnic-historical right to the territory.”
Book Summary by GROK 4 — (henrymakow.com)
Shlomo Sand’s The Invention of the Jewish People (2008, English translation 2009) is a controversial work by an Israeli historian that challenges the traditional Zionist narrative of Jewish history and identity.
Core Thesis
Sand argues that the idea of a unified, continuous “Jewish people” — understood as a single ethnic-national group with shared biological origins in ancient Israel, forcibly exiled by the Romans, and later returning to their ancestral homeland — is a modern invention rather than a historical fact.
This concept, he claims, was largely constructed in the 19th century under the influence of European nationalist ideas (especially German concepts of the “Volk”) and solidified by Zionist historiography to provide ideological justification for the establishment of a Jewish state in Palestine/Israel.
Key Arguments
GB News
433.3K Followers
Council tells man his flowerpots are illegal after he put them outside to brighten up his street
Story by James Saunders • 1h •A council has told a local homeowner his flowerpots are illegal – but he says he only put them outside to brighten up his street.
Peter Langdon, 57, had set down some containers filled with primroses, alliums and tulips on the pavement next to his home in Hamble, on the south coast.
Putting these flower pots outside his home in full view of passers by isa disgusting crime
i am shocked he did this.
no mention of migrant gangs, epstien blackmailing, dirty jewboy theft
pedophiles running amok, does not matter, but serious crimes like putting flower pots outside your home must be stopped
Another grok post, when he himself tells you “AI” is the devil’s balls.
Another post telling you most jews are “nice”.
Another post telling you about the past and how you should do as you’re told because the jews say such-and-such happened.
Baywatch icon Alexandra Paul was arrested in Wisconsin over the weekend after taking part in an operation that freed beagles from a controversial breeding facility for experimentation
The actress, 62, was taken into custody on Sunday morning and later booked in county jail on one count of trespassing, according to the Dane County Sheriff’s Office.
She was arrested after allegedly taking part in a protest at Ridglan Fars, a facility in Blue Mounds that breeds beagles. The dogs are used in scientific research for the military and medical industries and the facility has repeatedly drawn the attention of animal welfare activists.
A mugshot of the beautiful actress saw her in a blue jail-issued shirt over a brown t-shirt, with her hair pulled back in a ponytail.
In a press release on Monday the Dane County Sheriff’s Office stated that ’50-60 protestors entered the property without permission’ and began ‘removing numerous dogs.’ A total of 20 people were arrested.
Paul has been arrested a number of times over the years for acts of civil disobedience tied to various causes, including animal rights activism.
Baywatch icon Alexandra Paul, 62, was arrested in Wisconsin on Sunday after taking part in an operation that freed beagles from a controversial breeding facility; Pictured in her mugshot
Baywatch icon Alexandra Paul, 62, was arrested in Wisconsin on Sunday after taking part in an operation that freed beagles from a controversial breeding facility;
In the UK Rothschild own all animal experimentation, the expansion of animal experimentation meant Tony Blair and David Blunket got an unnamed number of shares
Does it really matter? Jews were a mass of mongrels to begin with, whether these mongrel Ashkenazi Jews can directly trace their descent to the ancient mongrels of the OT is irrelative–since the basis of Judaism is mongrelism. A rose by any other name… The origin of this group of people termed ‘Hebrews’, “Israelites’, & Jews’ is miscegenation. Jacolliot, Nietzsche & Blavatsky prove they descended from the mongrels of India known as ‘Chandalas’. Edouard Schure in a similar vein, affirms that the ancient Hebrews-Israelites were a product of white-black miscegenation.
now you know
A.A.
A bit more obfuscation of the real truth. Look at the Ulster flag of Northern Ireland. It has a red hand within a star of David. Jacob’s 4th son Judah had twins: Pharez and Zarah, There you have it: Zarah means red and king David was of the Pharez line of Judah. https://JAHTruth.net/uflag
Neither the Palestinians nor the Ashkenazis and Sephardics are of the line of Judah.
Israel, the country, a man made entity in 1948, is not what is referred to in the Scriptures. Israel is a population of people, who have been scattered across the world. Israel, the country, is populated with Arabs and Muslims and Ashkenazi Jews and other Dupes. I doubt that there is more than a hand full of true faithful followers in that country.
Enough of this ((( mind- screw clusterf*ck.)))
This is not much different than the Mafia.
A group forms a cabal with rules, blood oaths and doctrine.
This group is engaged criminal actions.
To survive (((they ))) con the Non Jews(Goyim) that they are the chosen of some fictional god.
(((“Membership”))) is via a maternal bloodline(mothers were sluts back in the day…temple prostitutes whereby actual father could thus not be ID’d)
Non members are Goyim..cattle ,..slaves, useful idiots and/or future sacrifices.
HOWEVER…If a critical mass of Goyim figure out these are Luciferian Satanists and nothing more ???
..all bets are off !!!
LOL…
Morons just don’t seem to get it, if the jooz are fake and the black book..the Bye Baal a provable fabrication..which it is*…then all the other abrahamic cults are too..
Obviously…but imbeciles are very selective..and with all this type of mythological drivel it’s so ambiguous..it can mean just about anything…it’s hard to be objective…better to trot with the flock..
that’s why these re-legions have their scribes and philosophers to spin it all out and create monoliths of mind control from the fifth dimension…which incidentally seems to acrue them great wealth..strangely enough..
there is a Truth, and I’ll let you know it, although I shouldn’t..there IS, lol, an intelligence that sits between your operating system and your sensory array…it can even communicates with you via your own thoughts.. but always intercessionary**..the KEY is to remove it..not worship it…
try it at home as it ventures to redirect you train of thought…observe it..go on..
* the best book is obviously psalms which was stolen from the Egyptians.. and sits in the Grimoire like a diamond in a cess pit..
** LOL catholics had this covered…
There may not be a continuous Jewish identity as constructed, but there is a definate Neanderthalic Tribal identity of a people who invaded the area.
Shlomo Sands is dead on, but it is much worse than just imposter jews.
The Holy Bible and the Torah are fake, totally fake made up bullcrap.
Abraham never existed, neither did King Solomon or King David.
Jesus is total fiction also.
All this death and destruction because people are hooked on the book and believe it real.
No god chose no people
No god judged us back then or now
No god hung on the cross for your sins
No one has ever walked on water or rose himself from the dead.
If you believe any of those things you are under a word spell.
Love Semites
…Hate kikes…
Another glimpse into the occult scum that is so powerful nowadays, and becoming ever more popular:
https://www.thewisewolf.club/p/hollywood-babylon-the-american-whore-story-antichrist-nuclear-war-child-murder-witchcraft
“Jesus is total fiction also”
—
Hardly. The Talmud states that Jesus is in hell in a cauldron of boiling excrement.
You don’t aim your most intense hate at a fiction.
The hate Jewry in general has against Jesus today, isn’t a “total fiction” either . They clearly tell us that they are proud of having crucified Jesus and that they would glady do it again today.
Now, many people that have made “debunking Jesus” the central point of their lives, will tell us about the many historical “Jesus” or crucified saviors, probably thinking “aha, now I finally defeated Jesus”.
But they miss the point entirely.
Such legends have a common origin long, long ago, when humanity was still very young and recognized the necessity of a savior after the “fall”.
These legends illustrate the hope for a promised savior, promise that was given to humanity from the very start, and which promise we can also see in the biblical book of Genesis.
So, the many legends of some “Jesus”, worldwide, doesn’t disprove anything.
The opposite is the case, the same as with the worldwide legends of the deluge, they don’t “debunk” the deluge but rather give it more credence.
Gregory Delaney exposed what lies lie behind the He rew “religion,” and thus it’s red handed step-child Judaism, and her two ugly sisters, Christianity and Islam.
“The Sumerian Swindle” and “Monsters of Babylon.”
Both are usually free online. Get the third and fourth editions, respectively, for citations and footnotes.
The crimes revealed still influence your life and happiness in countless negative ways.
I have both books “the sumerian swindle” and “the monsters of Babylon” since many years ago, they were part of my “formation”.
I can’t vouch for Islam because of my insufficient knowledge in that theme.
But picturing Christianity as an ugly “religion” is rather ignorant at best and malicious at worst.
The bad faith in the phrase is evident.
The only Christianity we may qualify as “ugly” is “christian” Zionism, while other kinds of Christianity are corrupted because they have been infiltrated with satanists and freemasons, both of which make no secret that they strive to destroy from within by corrupting them. But here the ugly part is , or is produced, by freemasons, satanists, witches.
Witches tend more to infiltrate small churches.