America Is No Longer A Nation

Paul Craig Roberts – April 10, 2019

The America in which I grew up and lived my early adult life was a nation. Over the course of my life I have watched my country turn into a Tower of Babel. Homogeneity and shared values permitted us to understand one another. This doesn’t mean that there was uniformity or that things were perfect. A Baptist wasn’t a Catholic. A WASP was not a black laborer. A female was not a male. Blacks and poor whites had a hard time becoming middle class, but it could be done. It was possible for middle class people to become “well off,” but difficult to become rich. Immigration was controlled, and the reduction of inflows had helped the Irish and Italians to integrate into society.

Police were helpful and didn’t burst into homes with guns blazing or rough you up on traffic stops. On important issues, compromises could be reached and reforms implemented. English was the language. If you telephoned a service provider, utility, or bank, you quickly were connected to a real person capable of handling every aspect of whatever you were calling about. Today you wait through the Spanish language option for the robo-voice listing the options that might have something to do with the reason for your call. The companies save money and make profits by imposing their service costs on customers.

Technology seems to have worsened the functionality of society. Diversity and multiculturalism definitely have. It used to be that taking or giving offense was something that good manners prevented. Today members of those groups that are entitled to be offended are ready to take offense at any excuse. Today it is easy for a white person and a male to give offense without intending or even knowing that what he did or said was offensive.

Diversity and multiculturalism provide a fertile field for Identity Politics. Identity Politics has succeeded in turning everything white into racism. Indeed, the word “white” is now a code word for racist. Western Civilization and science itself are explained as mechanisms of white domination. The other day a black female college professor declared time to be white. She explained that a tendency on the part of blacks to be late was due to the fact that time was just another white racist construct. Time was white because it made blacks late.

According to Identity Politics, white people are in charge, but the evidence is to the contrary. There are no quotas for whites in university admissions, hiring, and promotion. It is the allegedly victimized “preferred minorities” who get to go to the front of the line. There are no hate speech or hate crime protections for whites. Whites can be called every hurtful and offensive name in the book and have no right or power to demand apologies or the firing of the offender. White DNA has been declared to be “an abomination,” and white people “shouldn’t exist.” In America today, the way to get ahead is to claim victim-hood. Jews are experts at this, and blacks, women, and illegal immigrants have learned the same trick.

University education explains white people as the source of all evil. This is especially the case in what is called black studies and in gender studies, which seems to have developed out of women’s studies or feminist studies. A white male professor who gives a low grade to a female or to a black can expect that some charge might be made against him, but a white male who receives a low grade from a black or feminist professor has no such recourse.

As whites still constitute the majority of the U.S. population, what are the consequences for society when it is the majority that is constantly demeaned? What does it mean when white males, still the backbone of the military, are more easily cowed than women and “preferred minorities”?

When whites become a minority, what is their fate when the new majority has been taught hatred of whites for decades?

What does it mean when Americans fall all over themselves to apologize for using some word or term that someone finds “offensive” when it never occurs to Americans to apologize to Libyans, Iraqis, Syrians, Afghans, Yemeni, Somalis, for destroying the lives of hundreds of thousands of them? The disconnect here is extreme. Words hurt but not bombs. Moreover, I can remember when words now said to be offensive gave no offense to anyone. What has happened is that people have been taught to regard the words as offensive. How else did “girls” become offensive? Identity Politics finds more offensive words every day. Before long a white person will not be able to open their mouth. Language itself is being made dysfunctional. If the means of communication is dysfunctional, how can society be functional?

Identity Politics has produced disunity. Disunity is the antithesis of nationhood.

There are in the U.S. many groups that specialize in teaching hatred of whites by pretending to fight “white supremacy.” A new one on the scene is the Center for Jewish Civilization at Georgetown University. Georgetown is, or was, a Catholic university. One might expect a Center for Catholic Civilization or, as Georgetown is located in America, a Center for American Civilization. But no, it is a Center for Jewish Civilization. Who finances it? Why is it focused on “the far right”? Why is it at Georgetown University?

On April 10 the Center for Jewish Civilization at Georgetown University is hosting an all day propaganda session at the National Press Club to work up opposition to white gentiles who are allegedly using Nazi techniques to attack Jews and blacks. In other words, the Center for Jewish Civilization is doing precisely to white gentiles what the center claims white anti-semites are doing to Jews and blacks. The “conference” is focused on “How Do We Deal with a New Ecosystem of Hate and Anti-Semitism on the Far Right?”

We all know what the “far right” is—white people, which as a group are being recast as “white supremacists.” Far right is not a term ever applied to blacks or other races.

Try to imagine a Center for Palestinian Civilization at Georgetown University that was hosting a National Press Club all day event to combat an “Ecosystem of Hate and Anti-Palestinianism in Israel.” The center would be lumped in with the Alt-Right and accused of promoting hate and anti-semitism.

Or suppose U.S. foreign service veterans formed a Center for American Foreign Policy and criticized Israel’s control over American Foreign Policy revealed in Netanyahu’s boast that at his request Trump named Iran’s Revolutionary Guard, a large chunk of the Iranian government, as a terrorist group. The center would be accused of anti-semitic tropes.

How is a country a nation when it cannot have its own foreign policy, when words of its language are proscribed, when alleged victim groups have more rights than the alleged dominant class, and when hate is used to create disunity?

Identity Politics is the ideology that has been used to break America into disunited pieces.


Paul Craig Roberts is an economist, commentator and former Assistant Secretary of the U.S. Treasury

5 responses to “America Is No Longer A Nation”

  1. To correct our crazy discourse, try using this word substitution…

    “Far right” = “Completely right”


    “Far right” = “Absolutely right”

    : )

  2. ” The America in which I grew up and lived my early adult life was a nation. Over the course of my life I have watched my country turn into a Tower of Babel.”

    The world is covered in darkness.
    The United States of America is a covert dictatorship whose time has come.
    Guantanamo Bay tells it all.
    It is judgment time.

    The faithful witness
    Source: “Believers Information Network”

  3. Its Called Elitist Fascism

    What is happening is that the high echelons of society are ever more in league with the inner workings of the US government. This close tying together of the “rich” (its in quotes because these “rich” didn’t earn it, they manipulated to become rich) and government (the so called Shadow Government that never changes and controls the White House – for example, how Trump betrays those whom voted for him) is what in the old days was called fascism. But today it has more to do with the elitist element of high society and government, hence, Elitist Fascism. How sad is it, when just being rich isn’t enough to considered elite!

    There are basically separate laws for the lower classes, while the extreme upper class with its cozy government relationships are more or less immune from any legal problems, unless you cross the fascist Shadow Government. For example, Julian Assange, is going to pay a very heavy price.

    The United States has now become a fascist state. It doesn’t matter whether the left or right are in power, the elitists will stay in control. This is why the middle class is disappearing, as the elitist fascists look to getting more and more control and thus more and more wealth, the average American will suffer more and more. The problem is that the top few percent of society are now taking so much from the rest of society that they need the government to restrain forcibly or worse destroy anyone that gets in the way, of the rich getting more and more wealth.

    This is all eventually heading to one horrible conclusion. This is how super powers die, they end up pushing the rest of the world to unite and overcome their insatiable appetite for more wealth and control. History is replete with super powers using their positions to enrich the few at the expense of the many, and eventually paying a fatal and horrendous price.

    Ladies and gentlemen, the United States Of America is in its last years or decades, and like any super power that is facing internal economic annihilation, it will destroy all around it while it dies.

    Those rich and have a close hand on government will never allow Society to have more (money, food, or even happiness). This is why money and power should never be allowed to mix. Now watch how, like any period before a war, the lies and propaganda will spread from governments and those elite backing the government to point at others for the troubles occurring in the USA.

    This is fascism. But in the USA it is elitist fascism, for the ordinary rich are no longer good enough. As for the rest of us? Do you really need me to paint you a picture? The history books are replete with the nightmarish endings of super powers and the rest of the world.

    Do you really think Humanity is any different today, than at any other time in history?

  4. Dorian is absolutely right. We are watching the death of an empire. The moment (and perhaps that moment was from its very founding) that the US sought to become an empire, we were doomed. If we’re lucky, we might be able to end our reign as the world’s superpower with a status akin to the British today. I doubt it. But that really is the best case scenario. More than likely, we will see the US balkanized and it will cease to exist as the United States anymore. Maybe those poor Palestinians will be given North Dakota or some other state so Israel can finally have all their land. Whatever happens, it ain’t gonna be pretty. And even those elite WASPs who sold their souls to their AIPAC masters are going to be suffering because they’ll be “left behind” to be the scapegoats when the real “elite” jump ship like the rats they are. I just hope the Chinese really are smarter than we are. But, greed usually trumps intelligence — so I’m pretty sure they will fall for the devil whispering in their ear.